The FBI and Riverside police say that the Zodiac Killer case remains open and are refuting Wednesday’s findings from a group of veteran investigators who believe they’ve uncovered the true identify of one of America’s most notorious serial murderers.
‘The case remains open and there is no new information to report,’ the FBI said in a media statement after the group, known as the Case Breakers, released a bombshell report identifying the feared killer as Gary Francis Poste.
San Francisco homicide detectives say that identifying the Zodiac Killer must come down to having hard evidence like handwriting and fingerprint samples, which the Case Breakers analysis lacks.
But the collective of investigators say the FBI and San Francisco police are sitting on DNA evidence from one of the killer’s alleged victims and refuse to analyze it to compare to Poste’s DNA.
The FBI and Riverside Police Department say that the Zodiac Killer (sketch) case remains open, despite veteran sleuths claiming to have identified the killer as Gary Francis Poste (left)
The sleuths say that the FBI is sitting on DNA evidence that could tie Poste to the murder of co-ed Cheri Jo Bates, but refuse to test it. While the Riverside Police Department said homicide detectives have ruled out any links between Bates’ murder and the Zodiac killer
Bates was found stabbed 42 times and nearly beheaded in an alley in Riverside, California, in October 1966, two years before the Zodiac Killer’s first known murder
Poste died in Groveland, California, on August 14, 2018 at 80 years old – before the Case Breakers said he could be brought to justice for the string of gruesome murders plaguing the Bay Area in the 1960s.
The collective includes 40 independent investigators, including former federal agents, prosecutors, retired Army intelligence officers, investigative journalists and academics.
The group claims Poste killed co-ed Cheri Jo Bates, 18, who was found stabbed 42 times and nearly decapitated on October 31, 1966, in Riverside. However, the murder happened more than 400 miles south of San Francisco and two years before the Zodiac’s first known killing.
But the Case Breakers claimed that around the time of Bates’ murder, Poste, an Air Force veteran, was getting a check-up at a hospital located just 15 minutes away from the crime scene.
The sketch of the Zodiac suspect shows what is claimed to be a scar on the forehead. Investigators believe Poste’s photo at age 25 shows the same tell-tale scar
The Riverside Police Department received the above confession latter from an anonymous person claiming to have killed Bates. However, in 2016 the note’s author said he was a ‘disturbed youth’ seeking attention and his letter was a hoax
The FBI used the letter to release the above memo in 1975 to describe Bates as the Zodiac Killer’s sixth victim; The Riverside police now say they have ruled out any connection between Bates’ murder and the serial killer
A wristwatch splattered with paint and believed to have been worn by the killer was found near Bates’ body. Case Breakers noted that Poste spent 40 years working as a house painter.
Additionally, a heelprint found in the dirt at the scene of the stabbing was said to have been been from a ‘military-style boot’ consistent with the style and size of footprints found at three known Zodiac crime scene, and also of Poste.
The Case Breakers say that Riverside police have preserved samples of Bates’s hair, skin and blood found under her fingernails. However, they refuse to compare any of that DNA with Poste’s to determine if he was her killer.
The Case Breakers add in their findings that police were ruling out anyone who lived outside of the county as the killer.
Officer Ryan Railsback, the spokesperson for the Riverside Police Department, told DailyMail.com that their homicide unit, working with FBI genealogists, has ruled out any links between the Bates murder and the Zodiac killer, or anyone being potentially identified as the Zodiac killer.
A year after Bates’ murder, the Riverside Police Department received an anonymous letter, whose author appeared to confess to murdering Bates for turning down his romantic advances.
In 1975, an FBI memo sent to the Riverside Police Department linked the Bates murder to the Zodiac killings, describing the 18-year-old woman as the elusive murderer’s sixth victim.
The Case Breakers also relied on accounts of people who knew Poste, including a neighbor named Gwen (left) whom the alleged serial killer and his wife used to babysit as a child. They also spoke to a woman named Michelle, who said Poste has a criminal ‘posse’ and sicced members of it to harass and intimidate her
The Zodiac Killer’s notorious ‘340 Cipher’ (pictured), which was sent to the San Francisco Chronicle 51 years ago, was cracked by an international code-breaking team last year
Full text of ‘340 Cipher’
‘I hope you are having lots of fun in trying to catch me.
That wasn’t me on the TV show, which brings up a point about me.
I’m not afraid of the gas chamber.
Because it will send me to paradise all the sooner, because i now have enough slaves to work for me.
Where everyone else has nothing when they reach paradise so they are afraid of death.
I am not afraid because I know that my new life will be an easy one in paradise.’
However, Railsback said the FBI used the confession letter to tie Bates’ slaying to the Zodiac killing. In 2016, the letter was revealed to be a hoax.
An anonymous writer sent an unsigned, typed-up note to the police, revealing that they had sent the bogus confession, which was in fact a cry for attention from ‘a troubled youth.’
Railsback stressed that the Bates case remains open, and there is still an active $50,000 reward being offered for information leading to an arrest.
The police spokesperson noted that last month, an entertainment lawyer with alleged ties to the Case Breakers reached out to the department, saying that his client had information about the Bates case, and asking if the tipster would be eligible to receive the reward money, even if the alleged killer was already dead.
Railsback said he expressed interest in the information but never heard back from the attorney.
‘If we really had information that the Zodiac killer was related to Cheri Jo Bates, we would not hide that,’ he stressed. ‘We’re not going to hide information, especially 55 years later.’
But the Case Breakers theory goes further. Using photographic evidence, they point to another clue as a scar seen on sketches of the Zodiac Killer that resembles one in photos of Poste over the past six decades, Fox News first reported.
They also relied on accounts of people who knew Poste, including a neighbor whom the alleged serial killer and his wife used to babysit as a child, a man who claimed to have been a part of Poste’s criminal ‘posse’ that roamed the High Sierra region, and an ex-girlfriend of Poste’s son.
Five people were fatally stabbed or shot to death in Northern California in 1968 and 1969, and their killer sent taunting letters and cryptograms to the police and newspapers.
The killer was dubbed ‘Zodiac’ because some of his cryptograms included astrological symbols and references.
The series of unsolved murders inspired a plethora of books, documentaries and movies, with one of the most realistic to the real story being David Fincher’s 2007 ‘Zodiac,’ starring Marek Ruffalo as an investigator on the case.
In 2020, a ciphered letter mailed to a San Francisco newspaper by the Zodiac killer in 1969 was cracked by a team of amateur code-breakers from the United States, Australia and Belgium.
According to code-breaking expert David Oranchak, the cipher’s text includes: ‘I hope you are having lots of fun in trying to catch me. … I am not afraid of the gas chamber because it will send me to paradise all the sooner because I now have enough slaves to work for me.’
Little is known about Poste’s life beyond the fact that he was married, had a son, and worked as a house painter after retiring from the US Air Force, according to information gathered by the Case Breakers.
Despite his resemblance to the sketches, however, San Francisco homicide detectives say that identifying the Zodiac Killer must come down to having hard evidence like handwriting and fingerprint samples, which the Case Breakers analysis lacks
Betty Lou Jensen (left), David Faraday (center), and Darlene Ferrin (right), are believed to be victims of the Zodiac Killer
In February 2016, The Union-Democrat reported that 78-year-old Gary Francis Poste, from Groveland, was arrested at his home on Merrell Road on suspicion of inflicting corporal injury on a spouse.
A California woman who lived next door to Poste and his wife, and who had been babysat by the couple as a child in the 1970s and 80s, told Fox News she now believes her neighbor was the Zodiac killer.
The woman, who gave her name only as Gwen, Poste taught her how to shoot, sometimes going into the woods for target practice five days a week.
‘In the last year of her childcare, [Gwen] witnessed his callousness and violence towards his wife – a wife that only slept on a couch,’ according to the Case Breakers.
In a recent a phone conversation between Gwen with Poste’s widow, who is now in her late 70s and residing in an assisted living facility, the elderly woman was said to have told her former neighbor: ‘I’m sorry that I didn’t tell the cops about his past.’
A man named Hans Smits told the Case Breakers that over the past 10 years, he had been shielding a ‘Zodiac whistleblower,’ who had allegedly escaped from Poste’s criminal ‘posse’ that was said to have been active in the High Sierra area of California for several decades.
‘Now in his 50s and hiding in the Northwest, [the whistleblower] says he’s angry and ashamed, claiming the psychopath “groomed me into a killing machine,”’ according to the investigative group.
The whistleblower also claimed to have witnessed Poste burying murder weapons.
A woman named Michelle said she was the common-law wife of Poste’s son, and the mother of his grandson, who is now in his 30s.
According to Michelle, when her 10-year relationship with Poste’s son ended, the house painter sicced two members of his ‘posse’ on her, ordering them to break her windows, harass and assault her, ultimately driving her out of state.
THE ZODIAC KILLER’S VICTIMS
Although the Zodiac Killer claimed to have killed as many as 37 people in his letters to local newspapers, police have only linked five murders – and two other injuries – to him.
On December 20, 1968, David Arthur Faraday, 17, and Betty Lou Jensen, 16, were on their first date when they pulled over into a lovers’ lane on Lake Herman Road in Benicia. There, they were forced from the car by a killer and Faraday was shot in the head. Jensen began to run away but was shot multiple times in the back.
On July 4, 1969, Michael Renault Mageau, 19, and Darlene Elizabeth Ferrin, 22, were in the parking lot of Blue Rock Springs Park in Vallejo – 4 miles from the first crime scene – when they were shot ‘to pieces’, according to the investigator. But while Ferrin was pronounced dead on arrival, Mageau survived being shot in the face, neck and chest.
On September 27, 1969, Bryan Calvin Hartnell, 20, and Cecelia Ann Shepard, 22, were having a picnic at Lake Berryessa in Napa County when they were approached by a hooded man who bound and stabbed them. Hartnell survived eight stab wounds to his back, but Shepard died two days later.
On October 11, 1969, cab driver Paul Lee Stine, 29, picked up a passenger and drove him to Presidio Heights – where he was shot in the back of the head and robbed. The killer also ripped part of Stine’s shirt, which he later sent with a letter to a local newspaper.
Four other victims and one other escapee have been connected to the Zodiac Killer, but none have been confirmed.